Together, Phoenix R&D (developers of Air) and Okthanks hosted an open survey at the Global Gathering on the secure communications ecosystem. Three topics emerged: work-life separation, organizational use and adoption costs. These are accompanied by unmet needs, itemized below.
Topics
Defenders need separation between work and personal lives. Using the same phone number for different contexts concerns defenders. They do not want the same handle displayed for work, personal communication and activism. Some defenders use different profiles to create separation. Others complained, “I’m tired of opening the app to read a family message, only to get pulled into work.”
Building for organizations is both a strategic move and an area with missing features. Defenders set organization policies to increase adoption of secure tools. When helping organizations transition, onboarding, training and migration support are all needed. Secure communication training must consider the nuance of the context, as a tool will not automatically ensure security. Advanced features, settings or device security is often required for defenders.
Defenders are missing ways to manage conversations for organizational work. Groups with multiple channels (like Slack, Discord, Mattermost), one-to-many channels and threads were all raised as missing features. Further, defenders want best practices for using these features.
Adoption costs time, money and inconvenience. Learning a new tool takes dedicated time and often comes with losses. When defenders switch messaging apps, they lose connection with non-adopters. If switching from a zero-rated messaging app, switching costs money.
Among these, UX and technical difficulties prevent adoption. For example, if SMS codes are required for account creation, users who cannot get SMS codes are unable to create an account. If the app doesn’t just work or if notifications are unreliable, it’s difficult to continue.
Despite the costs, defenders are convincing peers and family to try secure tools. They’ve had success using social pressure—for example, organizing or spontaneously hosting download parties for groups to set up tools together; or personally refusing to share important documents or photos of grandchildren over less secure channels. Demonstrations have also proven effective—for example, live walkthroughs to introduce new tools and workflows to choose from; or illustrating how using insecure tools can put people at risk of arrest.
Unmet Needs
The missing features listed below are not specific to a single app. They reflect experiences using many: Signal, Mattermost, Webxdc, DeltaChat, Zulip, Teams, Element, Threema, Bitwarden for shared secrets, WhatsApp, Line, Instagram, Threads, Messenger, Simplex and Protonmail.
| Theme | Need |
|---|---|
| 1.0 Support for Global Work | Translation support, not only for the platform, but for conversations too
Features for better international communication (eg. schedule send or visibility into when people have notifications snoozed) |
| 2.0 Interoperability | Interoperability between messengers |
| 3.0 Security | Communications that allow registration without a phone number
Incognito keyboard that supports text to speech Separate profiles on the same app for work and personal use |
| 4.0 Low Bandwidth | Better support for low bandwidth networks
Ability to run on a local network |
| 5.0 Other Features | Usable voice and video calls
Local backup or export of chats Sticker packs Provenance support and AI detection |
If you are working on a secure communications app, consider this contribution as a starting point. Use the themes and unmet needs as topics voiced by Global Gathering defenders for further inquiry with your own defender audience. In doing so, you will understand the needs deeper and can begin to prioritize solutions.